Thoughts on Therapy News & Events

Cognitive Therapy or Psychoanalysis?


The goal of all good therapy is, in my opinion, to assist the individual
on his goal of individuation - or self-actualization.

But in order to truly accomplish this, it is my humble opinion that
the therapy must employ the methods of psychoanalysis.
Though psychoanalysis has gotten a kind of bad name over the past few decades, it is still the
only form of therapy that gets the client in touch with her unconscious self.
And it is this unconscious self which houses the complexes which
all too often defeat or frustrate our spiritual growth.

Regrettably, psychoanalysis is no longer the standard in therapeutic circles.
Therapists nowadays have been channeled into practicing cognitive therapy
as the norm. I think this is unfortunate, and largely due to an overpowering negative
influence of the insurance industry.

What’s Wrong with Cognitive Therapy?

The limitation of cognitive therapy is, quite simply this:
It doesn’t address the root-level, unconscious processes
which create the negative thought patterns the cognitivists
try so skillfully to correct.

Only depth psychology (of which psychoanalysis is a species)
can really get to these core, root-level issues. It’s not that
cognitive psychology has no use. It’s just that relying solely on
cognitive psychology to solve psychoemotional problems
is very like pulling an apple off an apple tree and expecting
the apple not to grow back next spring.

Eric Bryant, Philosophical Counseling Consultant
Gnosis Arts Multimedia Communications LLC


[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]

2 Responses to “Cognitive Therapy or Psychoanalysis?”

  1. habibi Says:

    Yes my unconscious mind went through a lot of trauma when the truck flipped over on highway 99. I didn’t even feel the truck flipping. Then the next thing I knew is the paramedic was giving me oxygen and telling me to focus on her, since I kept telling her that I want to take a nap while they jack the truck up and get me out it. It was an interesting experience. I always have a conversation piece but need to start getting over it since this happened 10 years ago. But I really believe that the accident affected the way I think sometimes. No, I do not mean that I got brain damage. The MRI on my brain came out normal, believe it or not. However, since that accident I believe it did affect me a little but I don’t know how it affected me. Sometimes I wish I would have died in it but them I think of my sister and she would be very sad.

  2. Eric Says:

    It is well document that accidents can cause the psyche to experience sever trauma. Think of PTSD and other related illnesses. Unfortunately, many psychologists are trained to avoid or dismiss the aspects of the psyche which are not conscious, or cognitive. And they are notoriously limited in helping post-trauma victims overcome their trauma, for precisely the same reasons.

    Thanks for your comment.

Leave a Reply

- Why ask? This confirms you are a human user!